Performance Face-Off: R449A vs R404A
Cooling Capacity: (Equivalent or slightly higher cooling power is provided with R449A.) One such study reported that R449A has a cooling capacity of around 7% greater than that of R404A.
This is due to R449A providing a far greater “cooling effect” (evaporator enthalpy change), an increase of approximately 23%, despite the lower mass flow rate.
Energy Efficiency (COP): R449A wins in this area. It tends to be much more energy efficient, often achieving about 5 percent more on average since some studies have shown 10 percent.
That means your system is working smarter, not running more, and it could save on your electricity bill.
Mass flow rate: R449A has a mass flow rate around 13% lower than R404A. this is because R404A has a larger density of suction line.
Discharge Temperature: Here’s the trick, R449A can have higher discharge temperatures, especially in low temp applications. Don’t worry – this isn’t a deal-breaker, but it may mean you must look toward additional compressor cooling, like liquid injection, for some of your semi-hermetic and scroll compressors.
Exergy Efficiency & Destruction: R449A has a higher exergy efficiency (approximate 5% higher) and a lower total exergy destruction compared to R404A.
In simpler language: your system is more efficient at converting energy into useful work, losing less in the process.
Life cycle climate performance (LCCP): This is the climate impact over the life of the system. LCCP of R449A peaks at roughly 95% of that of R404A. By the way, the majority of LCCP emissions result not from direct leaks of refrigerant, but from the energy consumption that results.
Pressure Levels: Saturated pressures for Shop R449A are slightly lower than R404A. You will have to set up your controls and your pressure settings appropriately.
Core Differences:
|
Feature |
R404A |
R449A |
|---|---|---|
| GWP | 3923 or 3940 | 1282 or ~1400 |
| Environmental Impact | High | Significantly Lower |
| Cooling Capacity | Baseline | Similar or slightly Higher |
| Energy Efficiency (COP) | Baseline | Up to 10% Higher, average 5% |
| Discharge Temperature | Lower | Higher in low-temp applications |
| Retrofit Feasibility | N/A (Original) | Good (with considerations) |
Contact Person: Mr. Raymond Chung
Tel: 86-13711988687
Fax: 86-769-22784276